Tag archive for "Bowl Championship Series"

Blog, College Football Playoff, Issues

BCS Arguments Proven Weak

1 Comment 13 March 2010

bcsmoneylogoThere are some who argue that the BCS is fair and just. It just so happens that they are the same people who happen to be paid by the BCS, BCS-affiliated conferences, or media companies who have million-dollar contracts with the organization. It’s uncanny. Really.

Furthermore, those proponents who get kick backs in one form or another have a laundry list of reasons why it’s so good for student-athletes and fans which needs to be cleaned on heavy duty permanent press spin cycle.

One major issue that stands out is the number of games NCAA football teams would be forced to play if a playoff was instituted. those poor souls. The argument from those in the BCS’ pocket stresses the importance of each game in the current system and how additional games would dilute and weaken the weight of games which are so potent under the current structure.

To borrow the title of the SNL skit hosted by Seth Meyers and Amy Pohler, the SFC counters this claim with a resounding and emphatic ‘REALLY?!?!’

Rather than provide a long list of reasons why the idiocy of the money-grubbing BCS’ arguments are just that, idiotic, let’s take a look at the Bleacher Report’s rankings of the Top Ten Most Cowardly Programs in College Football.

Notice any familiar faces or mascots?

It just so happens that many of these BCS don’t-call-it-a-National-Title contenders schedule cake walk games each year. While the teams themselves deserve some ridicule for padding their stats, it is obviously the system, the Bowl Championship Series - which rewards such behavior - that is truly to blame.

Sports fans deserve a playoff. Don’t let their henchmen fool you into thinking otherwise. Even if they hired 15 Ari Fleischers to spin the issue, we sports fans know a playoff is the only way to determine a true college football champion.

Uncategorized

Let The Champion Be Decided On The Field

No Comments 09 January 2010

It’s over now. #1 played #2 and #1 was victorious.

It was a great game, with a little of everything in it for college football fans – interceptions, injuries, trick plays, and heartwarming stories of players who faced adversity and kept going.

However, there was something just not right about it.  This is not the game we should have had.

AlabamaWinsIt has been over a month since the BCS, aided by computers (what would we do without them?), decided which two teams would face each other in its don’t-call-it-a-national-championship game. There were four more Saturdays of college football in which the fans could have had the playoff that included all of the best teams in football, not just those ordained by a group of insiders deadset on protecting their million dollar paychecks.

Joe Paterno said it best in a recent interview with ESPN. “We must have a championship game. We get forgotten after we finish the season. I don’t like the BCS. I think we need a playoff.”

The team with even one loss gets forgotten because their fate is decided immediately upon the regular season’s end. And what’s worse for teams that are not in an elite conference such as Penn State, even with a perfect season, a mid-major will be similarly exiled. Just ask Boise State how they felt after BoisebeatsTCUbeating TCU in the anticlimactic Fiesta Bowl.

As responsible sports fans, we want the college football season to last with an eye toward keeping our school’s athletes healthy – but with meaningful games leading up to the crowning of a true champion.

Without a playoff in the month of December, we will never know. If that means Alabama doesn’t play Jack State in September, so be it. We’d rather see an Alabama-Florida playoff rematch then the Florida-Charleston Southern blowout in Week 1.

Picking the final two teams for NCAA Football’s top prize  shouldn’t include a debate of what clique they hang out in. In this new decade, let the champion be decided on the field.

bcsmoneylogo

Uncategorized

Tonight We Dance in our Dreams

No Comments 07 January 2010

danceThere will be no BIG DANCE in 2010 much to the chagrin of college football fans across the country. Rejecting the pleas of sports fans, the BCS has shown hubris in deciding to not even consider implementing a playoff.

The Quinnipiac University National Poll numbers suggest that the public wants to scrap the current system for a playoff.  SFC board member Dave Zirin wrote an article published in the LA Times advocating for Congress to get involved.

While the public is split about 50/50 on whether Congress should lean on the BCS, the Sports Fans Coalition is not.  When sports issues enter Congress, there is a tendency for public disgust.  However, the public disgust over the inaction by the BCS is the greater evil in this situation.

In fact, rather than ameliorating the situation with sports fans, the BCS has hired Ari Fleischer to make their inaction look better, their stubbornness to appear like justice was served.

The truth is that no justice has been served.  It is an injustice that tonight’s college football game is the last of the season.  Texas and Alabama compete for a non-title while Boise State remains undefeated, and Florida overpowers Cincinnati for a consolation prize. 

There is no consolation for the college football fan.  There is no dance.

Uncategorized

Monday’s Call to Action by Brad Blakeman

No Comments 04 January 2010

blakeman_bradleyThe pressure is coming to bear on the BCS to change their ways. Momentum is building from fans and sports media and it is reaching the point where it is very likely that College Bowls will be “flushed” and playoffs will be instituted.

We are at a real tipping point. It has been said that there are 3 types of
people in the World; those people who make things happen; those people who watch things happen; and those people who never knew what happened. SFC needs people who make things happen and we need you now.

Together with your help, SFC can help put a stake in the heart of the BCS. We
need you to join SFC to help us help you make this happen. We are so close
to bringing equity and fairness to college football. A success in killing
off the bowl system will empower the fan to realize many more
accomplishments in areas like blackouts of games, ticket pricing, stadium
funding, etc.

Let’s double up our efforts today to help bring real change to college
football.

Uncategorized

SFC Board Member Dave Zirin Blows Whistle on BCS in LA Times

1 Comment 02 January 2010

bcsmoneylogoSports Fans Coalition board member Dave Zirin wrote a piece published in the LA Times yesterday delivering a scathing review of the BCS.

It’s entertaining, sickening, and informative.

Click on the link in the NEWS section titled ‘Congress Should Bench the BCS’. 

Especially for those still questioning whether Congress should get involved, it’s worth the read.

Uncategorized

Happy New Year from SFC!

No Comments 01 January 2010

bcsmoneylogo2009 was a tremendous year and Sports Fans Coaltion would like to take a moment to thank you for becoming a fan of SFC on Facebook, for following us on twitter, and most importantly, for joining SFC’s fight for Sports Fans rights as consumers represented in Congress and in every city across the country.

On this New Year’s Day, you’re welcome to sit back and listen to a very frank discussion on Intercollegiate Athletics in the 4th Annual Shirley Povich Symposium at the Phillip Merrill School of Journalism at the University of Maryland, College Park. 

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 1 – George Solomon

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 2 – Kevin Blackistone

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 3 – Symposium Part 1

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 4 – Symposium Part 2

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 5 – Stephen Heyer

Edge of Sports Radio – Segment 6 – Scott van Pelt

The symposium was broadcast as a special on SFC board member Dave Zirin’s Sirius XM Radio show Edge of Sports featuring Michael Wilbon, Stephen Heyer, Debbie Yow, Gary Williams, Kevin Blackistone, Scott van Pelt, and hosted by Connie Chung and Maury Povich.

Listen particularly closely to the debate on the Bowl Championship Series in which Michael Wilbon references the organization as a ‘cartel’.  Some excellent points from intelligent people on issues that affect sports fans. 

We look forward to a year of many possibilities for BIG issues to fall in favor of the sports fan.  The bigger we get, the more we can throw our weight around and get some traction on the issues before us. 

Join us today to start the year off on the right foot.

Happy New Year from SFC!

Uncategorized

Demands for NCAA Football Playoff Persist, Fiesta Dirt, BCS Ticket Prices Bowl Us Over

2 Comments 29 December 2009

BCSAs the New Year approaches, so do the infamous BCS games – which will once again deliver on the promise of leaving us wanting more. More entertainment, more justice, and more cash in our wallets. 

The results of a Quinnipiac University National Poll were released today finding that American college football fans favor a playoff over the current system 63%-to-26%.

While fans are on the fence about congress getting involved, the SFC applauds those representatives investigating the issue and bringing these abuses to light.  It is our hope that the BCS will realize it is in their best interest to listen to the lifeblood of their organization, the fans, and begin the process of implementing a playoff.

In other news, our comrades at Playoff PAC have filed a complaint against the BCS’s Fiesta Bowl for reimbursing employees for political contributions.  The Arizona Republic dug up some dirt on these BCS practices, and now Playoff PAC is asking that they open up their books.  We at SFC need a shower just reading this madness.  While it’s not exactly shocking, the BCS and the Fiesta Bowl should not be allowed to sweep this under the carpet.

Last, but not least, average ticket prices for both the Rose Bowl (1/1) and the BCS Championship game (1/7) are up significantly over last year.
 
The average sale price for Rose Bowl tickets is $467–a 21% increase over last year’s average $387, and the average sale price for BCS tickets is $1,117 – a 16.7% increase over last year’s average $957!

God bless you if you can afford to make it to one of these games.  God help us all to be able to watch the games on TV at home.

Uncategorized

Kerry Calls for TV Resolution Before New Year’s Day Football

2 Comments 23 December 2009

BLACKOUTTHE FOLLOWING PRESS RELEASE IS SFC APPROVED: 

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Senator John Kerry (D-Mass.), Chairman of the Commerce Subcommittee on Communications, Technology, and the Internet, today sent a letter to both FOX and Time Warner urging for a swift resolution to current negotiations in order to stop consumers, and football fans, from waking up without College Bowl games on New Year’s Day.  

“Fox and Time Warner need to strike a deal – millions of football fans are depending on it,” said Sen. Kerry.  “Having screens go dark because two parties couldn’t come together in time is no solution.  New Year’s Day and football are synonymous in households across the nation.  Private industry negotiations cannot disrupt a fundamental American tradition.”

The full text of the letter is below:

Mr. Chase Carey

President and Chief Operating Officer

News Corporation

1211 Avenue of Americas

New York, New York 10036

 

Mr. Glenn Britt

Chairman and CEO

Time Warner Cable

60 Columbus Circle

NY, NY 10023

 

Dear Sirs:

I am aware that FOX and Time Warner Cable have been involved for some time in negotiations regarding the terms of carriage for FOX-owned broadcast television stations, as well as FOX-owned cable channels. 

These are private negotiations, and I hope that the parties reach a mutually acceptable resolution before the existing agreement expires on December 31.  If you fail to do so, I suggest that FOX allow Time Warner Cable to continue transmitting programming through the College Bowl season either under current terms and conditions or under terms and conditions that will be retroactively applied once an agreement is reached, or under some third option.  I also suggest that both parties strongly consider entering arbitration rather than having consumers lose access to programming.

If I understand correctly, at midnight on December 31, 2009, FOX content may be removed from cable systems Time Warner Cable owns.  This means that, in January, millions of Time Warner Cable customers around the country could lose access to the Sugar Bowl, Cotton Bowl, Fiesta Bowl and Orange Bowl, as well as NFL playoff games.  Prior to the digital transition, many consumers were able to put up rabbit ear antennas to receive programming. However, digital receivers are more expensive and complex to use.  We do not want consumers waking up on the first day of the New Year wanting to watch football and instead finding that they have to take a trip to the electronics store to purchase a digital receiver in the hope that they receive a clear over the air signal.

As the Chairman of the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Communication, Technology, and the Internet, I have sought to place the interests of consumers at the center of our work.  If both parties conclude that the best alternative to a negotiated agreement is to have screens go dark for consumers, then they will have neglected the core interests of the millions of households that subscribe to Time Warner Cable in affected markets.  As leaders of major companies that are FCC licensees and are obligated to serve the public interest, I hope and expect that you will resolve this matter consistent with those obligations.

Sincerely, 

John Kerry

 

God Bless you, John Kerry, for working on this issue so near and dear to the SFC faithful’s hearts during this holiday season.  We need more politicians to speak up and speak out, advocating for the sports fan. 

We emplore you to follow up Senator Kerry’s letter with your own using the addresses above.  Let’s put the pressure on the networks to give us our games.  Let’s start the new year off with a victory!

Uncategorized

College Football Bowls Begin, Playoffs to Bring the Plagues

2 Comments 20 December 2009

Dick_CheneyThe NCAA Football Bowl Season has begun and, believe it or not, it’s been some pretty exciting football.  While the matchups aren’t especially rivetting on paper and actually reading the pre-BCS schedule filled with sponsor tags is a little like watching a NASCAR race, the competition has not been filled with ho-hum blowouts. 

A double-OT win for Wyoming over Fresno State in the New Mexico Bowl didn’t just make Dick Cheney smile.  A smirk was also found on the face of the Executive Director of the Bowl Championship Series Bill Hancock who has been spreading lies about how a playoff would hurt college football fans, and the economies of towns who currently host non-BCS bowl games. 

According to TIME Magazine, Hancock is one of the most loved men in the sports industry.  So, for those questioning the use of the word ‘lies’, it would be wise to read his unpalatable explanation predicting lost interest in the regular season, economic downfall for host cities of bowl games (assuming that host cities would have to change at all), and every other plague mentioned in Exodus short of raining amphibians, if in fact a playoff is instituted. 

ThePlaguesFurthermore, Hancock’s piece in USA Today illustrates how out of touch he is with the simple desires of the college football fan.  That is obvious quite early in this written plea, but never moreso than when he dares to state that ‘playoffs burden the fans’.  After going on and on about how great it is to create memories going on road trips to see one’s alma mater in the post-season, this becomes a ‘burden’ when it’s inconvenient for his argument.

It’s a healthy practice to examine the argument in detail.  It’s also a good excercise to pull back the curtain to see who is spending what on whom to get what done in terms of lobbyists’ efforts to influence our currently inequitable system for better or worse.  

One thing is for sure:  The SFC will be following this issue closely, pushing for a playoff with our friends at Playoff PAC until that goal is realized.  Awaiting Hancock’s smile turned upside down to pure frown.

Uncategorized

CONGRESS: ‘WE CAN WALK AND CHEW GUM AT THE SAME TIME’; ANTI-BCS BILL is HOUSE SUBCOMITTEE APPROVED

1 Comment 10 December 2009

ClintEastwoodYesterday, the proposed markup of the College Football Playoff Act of 2009 sponsored by Rep. Joe Barton’s (R-Texas)  was approved in the House Energy and Commerce Committee.

The measure, which SFC reported on and approved on Monday, “would ban promoting, marketing or advertising a ‘national championship game’ unless the game is part of a single-elimination playoff tournament like the National Football League playoffs, lest college football’s governing body be held in violation of Federal Trade Commission truth-in-advertising provisions.” 

The bill appeared to anger BCS Executive Director Bill Hancock who has repeatedly claimed that congress has ‘more important things to do’.  Sounds like a Karl Rovian or Fleischeresque, if you will, tactic focusing on the WMD’s.  That is, Weapons of Mass Distraction.  Fortunately, the subcommittee chairman and co-sponsor of the bill, Rep. Bobby Rush (D-Illinois) slapped Hancock down with a classic line, “We can walk and chew gum at the same time,” that could have just as easily been uttered by Clint Eastwood in the final scene of The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly.

For any still on the fence about the legitimacy of ‘congressional meddling’ in this instance, please read John Feinstein’s rant in Monday’s Washington Post.  It’s a scathing review of a system that’s more dysfunctional than your typical family gettogether around the holidays.




About SFC

SFC is the American sports fan’s advocate in the D.C. public policy arena fighting for sports fans in every city across the country.

Sports Businesses, Leagues, and Universities are grasping for our cash left and right. Let's join together to keep their hands off our wallets unless and until we have a say in how that money is spent. Futhermore, we sports fans believe we should be able to watch our games, no matter how we get our media.

Read More >>

SFC on Twitter